Jersey Mikes on Randell Road in Lake in theHills. Outstanding subs and service

There are several very good sub shops in this area. Jimmy Johns, Mikes, Bubs! We just tried Bubs last night and it was great. The staff is very friendly and made us feel very welcome.

Bub Subs!!!!

Happy Jacks Mchenry

A vote for Galloway's and the Algonquin Sub Shop from CL Facebook Page.

Algonquin Sub Shop. NOTHING else compares!

Algonquin Sub Shop is by far THE best!!! The South of the Border and the Californian are to die for... Great "skinny" fries too!

Yep, Algonquin Sub Shop for sure!

Bubs Subs in Algonquin!

Jersey Mikes... Philly Cheese Steak !!

Algonquin Sub Shop, the others are very good but rather ordinary. The creative subs at Algonquin Sub Shops puts them in a whole other category of deliciousness!

Jersey Mikes in Crystal Lake - Chipotle Turkey!

Grandpa's Subs in Algonquin on Route 31. Best sub for the money you won't leave hungry

Bub's subs on randall road in Algonquin!!!!! My favorite is turkey with provolone and ALL the fixens! Especially the giardinara! So delicious!

Definitely Bub Subs on Randall , the bread is amazing and the Italian beef is absolutely the best around (the ONLY place I'll eat Italian beef) , everything they make is amazing from the giardinara to the chipotle mayo. Yummmmmmmm and the owner is awesome and makes my el niño perfect everytime!!

Bubs Subs! If you voted for anything other than Bubs then you haven't been there yet!

Jimmy Johns.....just gotta love those sprouts!

Algonquin Sub Shop - Hands down the best.

Bubs Subs. I used to go to the various sub shops around but never could commit to one because I didn't feel any of them were particularly good enough to stand out from the others. I'd go to Jimmy Johns for the bread, Mike's for the Philly, etc. Since I've tried Bubs, I haven't went to one of these places (not once). When I'm in the mood for a sub I go here, lots of good subs to choose from, clean place. I love the toasted Bada Bing, Three Amigos, Club but most of all the Cheesy Italian Beef (with giardinera on the side-spelling?) Yummy!! By the way, I really appreciate the fresh vegetables too!

Bubs subs hands down!! #8 with chipotle mayo is delicious!!!

Algonquin Sub Shop. Make their own bread and sauces. x

Bubs Subs !!!!!!!!!! I love the Americano, oh yes let's not forget the Italian Beef the BEST I've had in years it melts in your mouth !!!!!

These Chowdown Showdown Challenges get nasty, back and forth with one another! Let me just say that those chain sandwich shops shouldn't be involved in these! Kept it to the small and local shops! Best sub...that's a tough one I can think of 3 pretty good places. Bubs Subs is a VERY good shop and so is Galloway's but then there is, to me at least, the King of them all since they have been in the area the longest, Algonquin Sub Shop. With that said though I got to tell you, if you give Bubs some time to grow they will march right up to the top of the Sub world. Final vote I am going to say Bubs. I just hope that the finalist are between local business. Don't forget Dino's Pizza has a mean sub! but lets keep Dino's out until a Pizza or Pasta showdown!

I agree with you completely Dino!! Forget the chains!! Have you ever had a sub from Butcher on the Block? It used to be my favorites right there with A.S.S. its been a little while since I have had them but they were great! I would say I put Butcher on the Block above A.S.S. then Galloways. I need to try a sub from Dinos next time but the Pizza is just too good to pass up on. Remind me to get a sub too next time!!

Bubs subs is it

Tried Bubs Subs for the first time and we all loved it. They had a nice selection of subs. The kids were able to get sandwiches for their size. And the taste was amazing.

I heard people talking about Bubs Subs! So I went to try it out. I was suprised to see the variety of sandwiches they offer. The veggies were so crispy! The meat was awsome! I recomend Bubs Subs to any sandwich lover!!!!

I go for Bubs!!!!

Can't find a sub comparable to HERO'S SUBMARINE SANDWICH SHOP on Addison and Milwaukee in Chicago. I have not tried any of the above mentioned stores, but will.

A vote for Jersey Mike's from CL Facebook.

Algonquin Sub Shop - it's been the best for years!

Bubs Subs. The price is reasonable considering just about everything is homemade. The variety of sandwiches is great, the vegetables are perfect, and the staff is great.

35 comments?! Wow! Good work, sub lovers. Keep the nominations coming. And if you really want to have your voice heard, don't forget to leave a review on your favorite restaurant's listing in our business directory, which can be found here: http://algonquin.patch.com/places

Algonquin Sub Shop!!!

Four votes for the Algonquin Sub Shop and two votes for Bubs Subs from the LITH Patch Facebook page.

Bub's Subs is the best!!!! I travel 52 miles just to get a sub from there. Everything is the freshest. Their homemade items are also great!!!! Wish there was one out by where I live!

Bubs Subs ROCKS! U can taste the quality of the bread and meat! Plus u cant beat homemade! Screw the chain sub shops!

I vote for Bubs Subs in Algonquin. They are a new place but consistently good every time. I get the Club Bub and the 3 Amigos subs; they're the best. A regular size sub is plenty and hits the spot.

Bubs Subs hands down.

Bub's Subs is the best, love the homemade Italian Beef on fresh bread!!!!

Algonquin sub shop for sure.

Galloway's. Best Italian Sub in the area!

Algonquin Sub Shop.....

Algonquin Sub Shop... Californian

Bubs Subs!!